Savages Critique Paper

Savages Critique Paper (17%):
Before we discuss this required book in class, you will turn in a 4-6 page paper that critically
discusses its content. I don’t want you to summarize the story but to analyze it. Assume that I
have read the book and simply discuss and evaluate the multiple social and environmental
conflicts it presents. Do not plagiarize or paraphrase from book reviews or other material – I
want to read your ideas and not someone else’s! Your paper should be well-written, reflect your
ideas, have a descriptive title (I like good titles!), be double-spaced, have 1-inch margins and be
written in 12 pt. Times-Roman (or similarly sized) font. Papers are due before class on October
5th.
Savages Critique Grading Rubric:
5 pts: Descriptive Title?
– Did student spend time coming up with an informative title? Is there a title?
10 pts: Double-space, 1-inch margins, 12pt font?
– Did student follow directions and use this format?
10 pts: Grammar?
– Paragraph and sentence format? Can I follow their ideas? Vocabulary and
word choice? Linkages between paragraphs and lead in sentences?
25 pts: Summary or Analysis?
– Is the paper a summary of the book (if yes, minus points according to how
much of the paper is a summary vs. an analysis)
– Do they delve deeper into the context of the book with their analysis?
25 pts: Evaluation of multiple social and environmental conflicts?
– Does the student discuss two or more conflicts encountered in the book?
– Are these relevant? Were these actual topics in the book?
– How well does the student present an argument?
25 pts: Independent ideas?
– Is it the student talking or is the student regurgitating text from a book review?